Understanding the current financial performance of your store as well as being aware of your institution's expectations for your store's financial goals are key to the success of your independent college store. The NACS Foundation Board of Directors has set financial standards as the initial focus of the Standards Project since these are the main yardstick used to measure the store's performance. As the first step in this process, the following financial standards have been set and were endorsed by the NACS Foundation Board of Directors:
- All Campus Stores (CS) must reach consensus between the campus administration and the store on the financial model the campus performance will be evaluated upon, to: a) provide a financial return, b) provide cost recovery, or c) provide services that may be partially subsidized by the institution, including promotion of student affordability initiatives and related pricing strategies.
- CS must routinely monitor financial results of the operation, comparing store location(s) and merchandise categories to prior year and budget, and including the following Key Performance Indicators (KPIs):
1. Sales - in total by channel: physical in-store retail & online ecommerce
2. Other Income
3. Cost of Goods Sold (COGS)
4. Gross Margin (GM) & Gross Margin Return on Investment (GMROI)
5. Price Changes (markups & markdowns)
6. Inventory Levels, Inventory Turnover, & Open-To-Buy (OTB)
7. Inventory Variance (shrinkage or overage)
8. Payroll & Benefits
9. Operational Expenses
10. Operating Margin (calculated as Gross Margin less Operational Expenses
11. Indirect Expenses & Campus Overhead
12. Net Income/Loss
13. Contribution to Campus
- In coordination with the overall campus administration strategic planning process, CS must adopt a strategic performance management tool or otherwise establish and adhere to a reliable methodology that includes a focused set of measurements to monitor against annual CS goals and objectives, as well as a mix of both financial metrics and non-financial/service performance data.
- A CS general ledger and the corresponding expense categories should be coordinated with the campus administration account definitions, especially where integration exists between a store’s retail system and a campus Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system to maximize efficiency and reconciliation. And where integration is not possible, output from both systems should be audited to ensure accuracy.
- CS should also measure and monitor the following metrics whenever possible at the store level.
- Balance Sheet Financial Results
- Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, & Amortization (EBITDA)
- Return On Invested Capital (ROIC)
- Economic Profit/Loss
- All Campus Stores (CS) must define, document, and manage procedures for basic financial controls, including:
- Bookkeeping – cash handling, banking, & deposits
- Cashiering, cash drawer, & checkout device security
- Daily sales reconciliation – for all methods of payment
- Internal/external fraud – including ecommerce transactions
- Credit/debit card security – Payment Card Industry (PCI) and related
- CS must benchmark financial results against other campus stores of similar type, size, and financial model using one or more credible and comprehensive industry financial surveys sponsored by an industry association or another method, identifying areas with opportunity for improvement, and developing detailed action plans for identified areas, implementing action plans, and conducting plan progress reviews.
- CS must understand the financial KPIs that are tracked and benchmarked and communicate those financial results with analysis and commentary to the campus administration or store’s board of directors, depending upon the ownership structure.
- CS must define inventory management procedures and guidelines, secure agreement from key stakeholders (e.g., campus administration, centralized accounting, auditors), document the agreed-upon methodologies and critical calculations, and share with all stakeholders. This includes any special processes for non-inventory items such as consignment, academic regalia rental, parking permits, bus passes, and other exceptions.
- Every CS must define a cost or retail method of inventory valuation and management. The process must assign an inventory cost value when the store uses the retail method of accounting to ensure alignment between store and campus enterprise resource planning (ERP) system values and should adhere to generally accepted practices of accounting, audit, and business records management.
- CS must take a complete physical inventory of the store’s merchandise for resale at least annually to improve the timeliness of variance reporting and effectiveness of management controls. The process should include reconciliation of the inventory as recorded with the store’s retail system and any centralized campus system inventory and investigation of any variance. In addition, the process should include appropriate audit controls to validate the physical count and detailed reporting of the inventory results.
- CS should conduct more frequent inventory cycle counts throughout the year, especially in instances that include, but are not limited to, the following:
1. When there is a high risk of a variance occurring and/or the financial implications of such a variance is significant
2. When the time and/or resources required to identify and resolve variances is extended such that earlier identification of discrepancies is beneficial
3. When variances have the potential to adversely impact business planning decisions, service delivery, or academic mission (e.g. discrepancies in course material availability)
- CS must audit inventory reports throughout the year to troubleshoot discrepancies and to facilitate a better reconciliation at year-end. Monthly auditing is recommended.
- CS must have a point-of-sale system (POS) that has the capacity to maintain, monitor, and report on a perpetual inventory. Functionality should take into account integration of sales and return transactions, taking a comprehensive physical inventory of the store, and reporting the shrinkage/overage variance with detailed discrepancies by item.
- CS that rent textbooks or other merchandise must define the specific accounting method that will be used, and this method must be practical based upon the type of rental program, such as short-term vendor partner programs and multiple-year, store sponsored programs.
- CS inventory reconciliation processes must control for accounting-related transactions, including inventory in transit, prepaid merchandise, accounting for chargebacks, and other exceptions.
- When calculating average annual inventory turnover, CS should use the method that incorporates thirteen month-end inventories so as to improve the accuracy of the calculation. However, as an alternative, CS may use the average of annual beginning and ending inventories as an approximation.
- To manage inventory effectively, every CS must establish an appropriate merchandise clearance strategy with annual projections by merchandise classification. Critical to maintaining a healthy open-to-buy, optimizing the merchandise assortment, and enhancing visual presentation, this strategy must take into account retail and industry clearance guidelines and:
1. Attend to inventory with a reduced marketplace value on a timely basis;
2. Address “broken-sized” merchandise through markdowns when not reordering; and
3. Account for merchandise obsolescence and book edition changes;
- CS must take markdowns at least quarterly throughout the year as needed in order to maximize inventory value and avoid skewing the annual performance at fiscal yearend.
- When determining inventory write-offs that may exceed guidelines, established strategy, benchmarks, or annual projections, the CS management decision-making must take into account the relative risk of further loss of value, marketplace demand, carrying costs, and appropriate campus communication. Examples include course materials that may change editions or seasonal merchandise that is only saleable at certain times of the year.
- CS should monitor inventory reductions (such as markdowns and point-of-sale discounts) by type or reason code to clearly distinguish between any reductions that are “uncontrollable” vs. those that are “controllable.” Examples of uncontrollable markdowns include staff discounts or a customer satisfaction accommodation. Controllable markdowns include planned sale promotions or adhering to established clearance policies.
- A CS general ledger and the corresponding expense categories should be coordinated with the campus administration account definitions, especially where integration exists between a store’s retail system and a campus Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system to maximize efficiency and reconciliation. And where integration is not possible, output from both systems should be audited to ensure accuracy.
- In coordination with the overall campus administration strategic planning process, CS must adopt a strategic performance management tool or otherwise establish and adhere to a reliable methodology that includes a focused set of measurements to monitor against annual CS goals and objectives, as well as a mix of both financial metrics and non-financial/service performance data.
- All Campus Stores (CS) must reach consensus between the campus administration and the store on the financial model the campus performance will be evaluated upon, to:
- provide a financial return
- provide cost recovery, or
- provide services that may be partially subsidized by the institution, including promotion of student affordability initiatives and related pricing strategies.
- All CS must utilize the established uniform industry classifications* for categorization of merchandise sales and other financial metrics to ensure comparability when benchmarking results against industry financial surveys and other metrics.
*Currently in collaborative development by NACS, CSC, & ICBA
- In addition, this analysis must take into account the overall contribution of the CS to the institution in both monetary terms and in a service context, as well as any special assessments levied on the CS as an auxiliary/ancillary enterprise and not applicable to departments and programs funded centrally through student fees or tuition.